Number of posts : 1426
Age : 22
Location : On The Moon.
Registration date : 2009-02-07
|Subject: OPPRESSED!!! Thu Mar 26, 2009 12:45 pm|| |
erm can D.D survivor come back??
I have a royal oppression faced up and a macros Cosmo on the field,
at the end phrase, my D.D survivor comes back.
my opp activates oppression.
D.D survivor goes graveyard, but with Macros Cosmo, it goes out of the game.
i am wondering, can it come back next turn???
Number of posts : 57
Age : 25
Location : singapore
Registration date : 2008-12-12
|Subject: Re: OPPRESSED!!! Thu Mar 26, 2009 1:21 pm|| |
I'm thinking the other way round.
It is countered in the out-of-play area. D.D Survivor didn't even touch the graveyard at all.
Man, if it does, isn't this an infinite loop.
Number of posts : 407
Age : 28
Location : Ki-Leng-Kia Land
Registration date : 2008-07-26
|Subject: Re: OPPRESSED!!! Thu Mar 26, 2009 1:49 pm|| |
Survivor will not return.
When this card is removed from play while face-up on your side of the field, you Special Summon it during the End Phase.
As seen above, it says you special summon during the end phase, this means that the "end phase" is on the current turn. When your opponent activate the effect of Oppression, he prevents D.D. Survivor from coming to the field. Hence, D.D. Survivor never came back to the field and so, he was never sent to the graveyard and never removed from the field. Therefore, it will not return to the field during next end phase.
Even if D.D. Survivor was to be special summoned to the field and was destroyed (say Torrential Tribute), he will not return to the field on the next end phase because D.D. Survivor's return to field is based on the turn that he was being removed from the field.
Number of posts : 882
Age : 24
Location : YuGiOh Singapore Community [ Senior Duelist ]
Registration date : 2009-02-22
|Subject: Re: OPPRESSED!!! Thu Mar 26, 2009 10:07 pm|| |
Survivor will come back cause it is destroyed on the field but the royal oppession only negates the special summoning only and destroy the mob. It will the same thing for Stardust too... When synro summon stardust, royal oppession use effect, stardust can pull that card to the graveyard with it... And return the end of the turn...
Number of posts : 1339
Age : 8
Location : admiralty
Registration date : 2007-12-21
|Subject: Re: OPPRESSED!!! Thu Mar 26, 2009 10:20 pm|| |
- Dknightz wrote:
- Survivor will come back cause it is destroyed on the field but the royal oppession only negates the special summoning only and destroy the mob. It will the same thing for Stardust too... When synro summon stardust, royal oppession use effect, stardust can pull that card to the graveyard with it... And return the end of the turn...
when u negate summon,means the monster didnt touch field.SDD will die w/o touching field
oppression works like solemn,they can only negate the source of the summoning
Number of posts : 1337
Age : 32
Location : Duelist Academy
Registration date : 2007-12-15
|Subject: Re: OPPRESSED!!! Fri Mar 27, 2009 7:21 am|| |
Oppression negates the card effect that sp summons/sp summons by own effects....
So the monster gets negated and does not even appear on the field, therefore....
DD Survivor never even appears on the field to "get removed from game again", and his effect gets negated for that time as well, so he does not appear.
Stardust dragon also never appears on the field because its summon is negated, so cant even perform "sacrifice itself to negate the card effect that destroys", so it just stays in the grave.
Trust me on this one, I've been dealing with oppression for 5 years, all the older players who know me can testify to it, LOL
|Subject: Re: OPPRESSED!!! Today at 8:24 am|| |
|Dear members, |
Be sure to post a message once you have been registered. As I had just cleared 100+ member with no post in the forum. I am trying to keep the forum neat and tidy. Those users who just create an account to just come in to look and see, I am sorry but I have deleted the account. I would believe only the trading post is will be viewable to members so there should be a need for a guest to create an account to see what events we are having.
Also take note that TRADING THREADs are going to be auto prune everyday. Condition will be a post every 7 days else it will be deleted. Again its to keep neat and tidy in the forum.
Thanks for understanding.